|
Topics: Community
A
Differences Approach
A
unique program helps cities like Fargo, North Dakota,
embrace racial diversity
A Differences
Approach is Creating Opportunity in Fargo, North Dakota. Through
a regional collaboration between Fargo, North Dakota and its
neighboring city, Moorhead, Minnesota, citizens are addressing
the opportunities and challenges of an increasingly diverse
population by implementing extensive educational and outreach
strategies to promote understanding of the different cultures
in the region. The community is one of fourteen working with
the Pew Partnership for Civic Change, which focuses attention
on the civic capacity of smaller cities. Case
study plus.
Case
Study Plus: A Differences Approach
by
John Yearwood, staff writer of The Dallas Morning News
Reprinted
with permission of The Dallas Morning News
In Civic Partners, Spring 1996.
Published by the Pew
Partnership for Civic Change.
Fargo, North
Dakota.
Third-grader
Robinson Tanazy grabs the hand of his fifth-grade friend, Nazar
Ahmed, and pulls him past half-full classrooms and down the hall
of Jefferson Elementary School.
The excited
nine-year-old stops just short of two dozen miniature flags that
represent countries from Bosnia to Vietnam.
"There it
is right there!" he shouts, pointing his 11-year-old Kurdish friend
toward the blue and red Haitian flag."See! That's my flag!"
Leaning
against her nearby office, principal Martha DiCicco has reason
to smile. The flags went up last year as part of an effort to
acknowledge Jefferson's transformation from a virtually all-white
school to one with nearly a 25 percent minority student body.
Jefferson
reflects the changing demographics of North Dakota, long an ethnically
homogenous state. The shift is most apparent in Fargo and neighboring
Moorhead, Minnesota. The area's minority population has more than
doubled in the past decade. Today, just less than 10 percent of
its 130,000 residents are minorities.
Local leaders
are trying to copy some of Jefferson's successes in a new areawide
project aimed at preventing the language and race problems that
have torn apart cities around the country.
"We want
to try and anticipate any type of problems that might come up
and avoid them," Fargo Mayor Bruce Furness says.
Fargo is
among a handful of cities that have started programs aimed at
addressing racial issues before ethnic or political crises develop.
"America
as a nation, is being pulled apart at the seams. We are the new
seam stitchers," says Sharif Abdullah, site director for the Three
Valleys Project, which is working to reduce racial conflicts in
the Portland, Oregon, area. "If we can pull together a new tapestry,
there is hope for us as a nation. If we can't there simply isn't."
Historically,
Fargo has been overwhelmingly populated by people of Scandinavian
and German descent.
John Zaharia,
22, grew up in Fargo; he didn't talk to someone of African descent
until he went to college. That would not be the case today, he
notes.
"Once in
a while I saw a black person go through town," says Mr. Zaharia,
a local funeral director. "Except for one Oriental family, the
entire [high] school was all white people."
Last year
Fargo, West Fargo, Moorhead and Dilworth, another Minnesota town,
won a $400,000 grant from the Pew Partnership for Civic Change
to launch the Cultural Diversity Project. Fargo officials have
spearheaded the project-- which benefits all four cities.
In a little
more than a year, the project's innovative efforts have received
national attention. Project organizers have been asked to make
presentations to the nation's mayors and nonprofit organizations'
leaders.
"I think
we have made some inroads in educating the community and increasing
the community's sensitivity toward minorities." says project coordinator
Yoke-Sim Gunaratne."That's a good first step."
Mrs. Gunaratne,
who was born in Malaysia and moved to Fargo a decade ago, says
the project succeeds because many residents are willing to accept
change.
For decades,
residents' interaction with minorities was mostly limited to migrant
workers from Texas who work on sugar beet farms in the summer.
At the season's end, workers gathered their belongings, pulled
their children from area public schools and moved back to Texas.
Minority
Influx
In recent years,
though, many have chosen to remain, particularly in Moorhead, where
the unemployment rate stands around 3 percent.
That has caused some tensions in the community,
says Hector Martinez, director of the newly created Hispanic Center
in Moorhead. About 2,000 Hispanics live in the city of 30,000.
Some whites have grumbled that Hispanics burden
the welfare system and commit crimes. Some residents complained
in July when migrant workers sought federal disaster relief because
two months of rains prevented them from working on the farms.
"If one
person is a welfare recipient or has a criminal history, then
some people say the entire community must be that way," says Mr.
Martinez, a former migrant worker. "It certainly affects us."
But he says
the center, formed with financial help from the Cultural Diversity
Project, has begun to educate the community about Hispanics.
"With the
project's help, we've been able to bring community leaders together
and say, 'Hey, we're in the same boat,'" he says."It's given us
an opportunity to create a sense of community."
Not far
from Mr. Martinez's office, down Main Street and across the Red
River, the project also helps Fargo's 77,000 residents cope with
the dramatic increase in refugee and American Indian populations,
community leaders say.
The number
of refugees arriving in Fargo has grown by more than 700 percent
since 1989, according to the Refugee Program of the Episcopal
Diocese of North Dakota and Lutheran Social Services of North
Dakota, a joint ministry that sponsors refugee resettlements.
Those who work with the refugees say Fargo is a logical new home
because the city's unemployment rate is low and systems are in
place to deal with refugee populations.
They come
from several international hot spots: Kurdistan, Haiti, Russia,
Bosnia, Zaire, Vietnam, Somalia, Sudan, Cuba, Armenia, Iraq. The
refugees, and increasing numbers of American Indians moving to
town from nearby reservations, had an immediate impact on the
city's schools.
School
Impact
At Jefferson
Elementary, Ms. DiCicco saw the minority enrollment double, then
quadruple, during the late 1980s and early 1990s.
Cultural conflicts quickly developed among her
280 students, she says. Many students questioned why some refugee
youngsters were served different lunches (some Bosnians don't
eat pork) or why they were allowed to leave class to attend English
language labs, she says.
Last year, the school won a $20,000 grant from
the National Coalition of Advocates for Students to create programs
to help students learn more about one another's culture.
The school brought in local residents from different
countries to speak to students, hosted potluck dinners and picnics
for parents to get to know one another, flew the flags of 18 countries
in the hall, and translated classroom names into four languages.
"We wanted
to do things that would make life better for residents here and
to help new people feel at home," Ms. DiCicco says. "We are convinced
that they [students] learned not just to see refugees as new students
but they learned some of the differences."
Ms. DiCicco
is working with community leaders to incorporate some of the successes
at Jefferson Elementary into the areawide Cultural Diversity Project.
The need
for education about cultural diversity emerged when community
leaders gathered two years ago to brainstorm about proposals to
win the Pew grant, says Kathy Hogan, director of social services
for Cass County and a project founder.
The cultural
diversity proposal won by one vote over others to seek a grant
to address underemployment and children's issues, she says.
"Some people
felt that there was really a change in our community and if we
applied for the grant and got it, we'll be admitting that there's
a problem and saying that we were going to do something about
it," she says. "That was a big step."
Local corporations
chipped in $150,000 in matching funds to fulfill a Pew Foundation
requirement.
Project
volunteers have helped train minority residents to serve on local
boards and commissions, and funded the formation of cultural centers
and cultural awareness programs at schools.
Organizers
say that long-range plans include establishing a language center
to help residents--more than a dozen languages are spoken in the
area. They also plan to lobby local school boards to implement
a multicultural curriculum.
"The feedback
has been very good," says Mr. Furness, the mayor. "People are
making an earnest effort to work together."
Some refugees
agree. "People have been very friendly," says Valeria Foni, 27,
who was resettled to Fargo from Sudan 17 months ago. She has joined
a church and works as a secretary with the refugee program. "I
talk with them about Fargo and my country."
Problems
Remain
But some refugees
say the area has a way to go before they feel comfortable.
Martins Muoang says he fled the central African
country of Zaire after his parents were killed in a car bomb.
He arrived in Fargo two weeks ago with a friend, Gervais Langando,
who had been jailed in the Central African Republic after he protested
his government's decision to allow European nuclear waste into
the country.
The men say recent incidents at a local park
and on a city street have left them wondering whether they are
really welcome. A man refused to let them borrow one of several
balls he was not using to play soccer, and a carload of teenagers
pointed and laughed at them as they walked home.
"Those kinds
of things made us very sensitive," says Mr. Muoang, 30. "We are
all human beings. I don't know why people would drive past in
a car and insult another human being."
Despite
the project's successes it would be virtually impossible to root
out all the prejudice in the Fargo-Moorhead area, several residents
say.
"A lot of
people mourn the passing of that little white Anglo-Saxon state
we used to be," says Joellen Smith, 45, a registered nurse. "For
example, people are quick to blame the entire group of migrant
workers for the actions of a few young men that sell drugs and
things like that."
At Jefferson
Elementary, students say embracing the community's diverse background
has worked for them.
"When I
came here I was scared and nervous. I didn't know any of the students
in my class. I was scared about them and they were scared about
me," says Nazar, who spent a year in a Turkish refugee camp before
being resettled in Fargo about two years ago.
"Now, we
know each other and we're not afraid anymore."
Resources
on Diversity
Drawing Strength
from Diversity. San Francisco: California Tomorrow,1994.
Julia Teresa
Quiroz. Together in Our Differences: How Newcomers and Established
Residents are Rebuilding American Communities. Washington, DC:
The National Immigration Forum, 1995.
Scott Walker,
Ed. Changing Community. St. Paul: Graywolf Press, 1993.
More Information
Yoke-Sim
Gunaratne, Project Coordinator
Cultural Diversity Project
810 4th Avenue South, Suite 147
Moorhead, MN 56560
Tel: 218-326-7277
Back
to Community Index
|